Recent reviews

Great experience, highly qualified agents and staff, professional and courteous
Bob S.

We like dealing with the people in this agency. They get us better deals if available and are readily responsive to our questions.
Margaret R.
Always good service and rates
Emily S.

Service has always been prompt concerning questions and when i first hooked up with their company they were able to save me money on my home insurance. and, I did give a referral to a friend in the Chatham area.
Stephen M.

I took over my father's insurance for his house when he died. They have been very helpful and I will continue to use them.
Elizabeth C.

Few years back we needed a home owners policy ASAP . Bryan P. Braley went out of his way to get us best insurance at competitive prices. Always answered all questions quickly and helped with all paperwork thru transition.Would recommend them.
Jojo S.

What I like best about Calfee is the PERSONAL service! So good to have that kind of response instead of something where you have to wait on the phone, etc.
Elinor H.

Great company, great service, I recommend to all people who need insurance!
Adao B.

Voted Best Insurance Agency in New England by yours truely.
Arthur C.

Greg W.

Arthur Calfee agents were very helpful to us when we were setting up new home insurance. They promptly provided us with options that were the coverage we needed and gave us the option of different, reasonably priced options. They returned calls walked us through the process.
R C.

Excellent company right here in our town. Great service. Thank you.
Jane 

This company has for almost 20 years provided us with top notch service. We highly recommend them.
Annelieke S.

The agents at Calfee are the BEST! Their patience and prompt reply to any issue is outstanding. They dutifully follow up and are kind, as a bonus! We appreciate them so much.
Tyler V.

Matheus R.

Most issues easily handled with an email. Cape insurance is a bit tricky and a good agency really helps.
Mike B.

Professional, friendly service. They really care about their customers and do what it takes to get you the best insurance at the best rate.
Merope D.

I had MPIUA insurance at our Cape Cod property for quite a while and decided it was time to go with a different insurer. MPIUA clients know the story. I was not in a rush. So I contacted four local agents in the area and Davidson Calfee was the only one to follow up and to see if I had made a decision. Made the deal on the spot. All other companies never called back. The policy was great and I have been insured with Calfee for 1 year. My interaction could not have been easier in setting up the policy specifics. I would recommend Calfee without hesitation. Thanks for the read.
jeffrey m.

Arthur D Calfee Insurance saved me a lot of money on my homeowners insurance. They shopped around until they found a responsible, highly-rated insurer that offered a reasonable rate. Luckily, I haven't had to make a claim yet, so I can't comment on that.
Bill C.

Excellent service. Responds quickly and always returns phone calls. Definitely would recommend to family and friends.
William W.

Bryan was able to get us an exceptional reduction on property insurance and the agency is knowledgeable and quick to respond to questions. Very pleased with the service and products..
Lucy B.

I've dealt with Bryan Brayley at Calfee, who has been very easy to work with, understanding of what I need for my house on the Cape, and willing to deal with questions promptly.
Bill W.

Great staff! Very helpful and friendly. Saved a lot of money by combining my home and car insurance with them.
Draper K.

The customer service at Calfee Insurance was incredible. I could not be happier with the experience I had and I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for car or home insurance. They are the best in the business.. Highly Recommended.
Fatima J.

Great experience with Calfee Insurance. Got best home insurance policy. Very transparent and prompt in service. They guided me carefully to know the policy. Highly recommended.
Michel S.

As a customer of Calfee Insurance since 2014, I can definitely give them a good complement. Good value and best home insurance. I never had a bad experience from 1st day. Highly recommended company
Andy J.

I have been a customer of this Calfee Insurance since 2016 and have never had a bad experience. I always get prompt, professional service from the staff. I often recommend Calfee when colleagues ask about insurance.
Rudolph C.

The customer service at Calfee Insurance was incredible. I could not be happier with the experience I had and I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for car or home insurance. They are the best in the business..
Mike S.

Great customer service, best rates and coverage for the price. Could not find better rates on the coast that covered wind. So relieved to have coverage under one policy.
Ajoy S.

Calfee Insurance stuffs are very professional and knowledgeable. I got a very good home insurance policy. I would like to recommend this insurance agency to my friends and family.
Debarup M.

Truly professional and very prompt in their service. I connected with a referral and got very good service. Best insurance agency. Thank you.
Daphne D.

A top notch Insurance agency. Loved to work with them. Best home insurance & great value. Friendly stuffs. Will definitely work with them again.
Raquel V.

Since 1980, the Calfee Family has endeavored to offer the highest rated companies to our clients. Our staff in both offices are highly trained insurance people who will answer promptly your insurance inquiries. Insurance quotes may be given for your home, car, boat, life & business. We have developed special, long term relationships with our company underwriters and insurance claim representatives to give excellent quality service to our clients.
Booje C.

I quoted around and they got me the best, most competitive, home insurance policy for the cape cod, ma area. And they saved me money on my car insurance too! Together they saved me a ton $$$
Keli A.

I live near the water on the Cape and had been searching for a reasonable homeowners policy. The fair plan was really not fair. I met with Calfee Insurance. They hooked me up with an A++ carrier and the policy had a miniscule 1% wind deductable for half the premiums of my old policy (by the way, my old policy had a 5% wind deductable). Half the cost and better coverage that is what Calfee can do for you. I would recommend them to the best of my friends.
Kevin P.

I recently switched my auto insurance to Arthur D. Calfee insurance. The experience I had with them was great - they got me a quote the same day, which was quite a bit lower than what I had been paying. The staff was knowledgable, friendly and helpful. They showed me how to go on line and pay my bill and walked me through exactly what I needed to do. Since I had such a great experience with them for my auto insurance, I had them quote my homeowner's policy, and had the same experience - personal service, great prices, they are by far the best agency I have ever dealt with, and I would highly recommend them!
Merope D.

Calfee Insurance is a great company, they not only saved me money but were so thorough that I got a more comprehensive coverage policy. They took the time to explain all the intricacies and variations in the Coverage. Since we live near the water we didn't think we had a choice in policies but Calfee explained that the laws have changed and new coverage is available. Now we could combine our Home and Auto and save even more. 

I would recommend Calfee to everyone because they are so easy to deal with, professional and do not pressure you. Like I said, they explain everything so you know what, why and how your policy designed just for you. I have my Home, Auto and Business policy's with them.
Michael R.

I recently got a quote from Davidson at Calfee insurance for insurance on my rental property. I had a fabulous experience there. I got a great rate, the ... Read More
M D.

I had just purchased a home in Cotuit and I needed homeowner's insurance and wanted someone in the upper Cape area to help me out, as I really didn't know ... Read More
David B.

Tracy McCarthy, Health and Life Insurance Agent, Independent Health Insurance Agent
I was with another company when working with Davidson O. at Arthur D. Calfee Insurance Agency, Inc. of Falmouth Ma.

"As an extremely personable and knowledgeable professional, Davidson assisted me in securing liability and workers' comp insurance for a new non-profit school that I am involved with as a volunteer and board member. His dedication to get us coverage in a timely fashion and handle most of the paperwork was outstanding. Davidson is a true professional (real estate agent) and gentleman; someone I would highly recommend to all my colleagues and clientele in Falmouth and Barnstable Ma." June 19, 2008
Joe M.

---