Report a CLAIM to Arbella Mutual Insurance
Click HERE to report your claim online
Report a CLAIM to Safety Insurance
Report a CLAIM to Travelers Insurance
Report a CLAIM to UPCIC
Report a CLAIM to Encompass Insurance
Report a CLAIM to MPIUA, the state's 'fair plan'
For Business 1-800-392-6108. Non Business 1-800-297-3554 or
Click HERE to report your claim online
Report a CLAIM to Plymouth Rock Insurance
Click HERE to report your claim online
Report a CLAIM to Preferred Mutual Insurance
Report your loss by phone, please contact 1.800.333.7642 or
Click HERE to report your claim online
Report a CLAIM
Report your loss by phone, please contact 1-877-763-1800 or
Click Here to report your Claim https://www.providencemutual.com/claims-overview/
Report your loss by phone, please contact 1-877-425-2467 or
Click HERE to report your claim online
Report you loss by phone, please contact 1-800-820-3242
or click here http://www.wrightflood.com/claims.html to report your Claim online
Report you loss by phone, please contact 1-800-364-7045
or click here https://fnol.kingstoneinsurance.com/Login?correlationid=e3a31d04-83e5-4889-bb9f-4301ef31430f to report your Claim online
|
|
Report you loss by phone, please contact 1800-626-9660 or
click here https://www.mfic.com/claims.php to report your Claim online
Ice Dams: How to Protect Your Cape Cod Home This Winter
![[HERO] Ice Dams: How to Protect Your Cape Cod Home This Winter](https://cdn.marblism.com/IbfCBcbdhMX.webp)
There is something quintessentially New England about seeing a row of glittering icicles hanging from the eaves of a Cape Cod cottage after a heavy snowfall. It looks like a scene straight off a postcard. But as someone who has been helping neighbors protect their homes for over 40 years here at Calfee Insurance, I see those "dazzling" icicles a little differently. To an insurance professional, those heavy ice formations are often the first warning sign of an ice dam: a winter hazard that can lead to thousands of dollars in water damage if left unchecked.
At Arthur D. Calfee Insurance Agency, Inc., we are a family-run business that understands the unique architectural challenges of living on the coast. From the classic Capes in Barnstable to the modern waterfront homes in Chatham, our local climate creates the perfect recipe for ice dams.
Understanding how these dams form and how to prevent them is one of the most important things you can do to protect your property investment this season.
The Science of the Freeze: How Ice Dams Form
An ice dam isn't just "frozen snow." It is a specific phenomenon caused by a temperature imbalance on your roof. Usually, they form after a heavy snowfall is followed by several days of sub-freezing temperatures. Here is the step-by-step breakdown of how your cozy home might be working against you:
- Heat Loss: Warm air from your living space escapes into the attic. This happens through bypassed light fixtures, attic hatches, or simply because of thin insulation.
- The Melting Point: This escaping warm air heats the underside of your roof deck. Even if it’s only a few degrees above freezing, it’s enough to cause the bottom layer of snow on your roof to melt.
- The Runoff: The melted water flows down the slope of the roof, tucked safely under the insulating blanket of snow on top.
- The Refreeze: Eventually, that water reaches the "overhang" or the eaves. Because the eaves hang out past the exterior walls of the house, they aren't warmed by the attic air. They remain at the same temperature as the freezing outside air.
- The Dam Construction: When the water hits that cold overhang, it freezes instantly. As the cycle repeats, a literal wall of ice builds up along the edge of your roof.
Once the dam is high enough, the melting water behind it has nowhere to go. It pools up on the roof, eventually finding its way under your shingles. From there, gravity takes over, and that water begins its destructive journey into your attic, ceilings, and walls.

Why Cape Cod Homes Are Especially Vulnerable
If you live in a traditional "Cape" style home, you might be at a higher risk than someone in a standard two-story colonial. Our local architecture often features sloping ceilings and "knee walls" on the second floor. These areas are notoriously difficult to insulate and seal properly.
In a Cape-style retrofit, it is common to find that the narrow space between the ceiling and the roof sheathing doesn't allow for enough airflow. This creates "hot spots" on the roof that accelerate the melting process. Furthermore, many of our historic homes were built before modern energy codes, meaning the attic insulation might be original: or non-existent. That’s why we always recommend a local inspection if you’ve noticed significant icicle growth in past years.
The Real Cost: Potential Damage to Your Home
Ice dams may look harmless from the sidewalk, but the internal damage they cause is often hidden until it's a major problem. If an ice dam is left untreated, it can cause a domino effect of issues:
- Ruined Attic Insulation: Once fiberglass or cellulose insulation gets wet, it loses its "R-value" (insulating power). It compresses and becomes a soggy mess that actually helps pull more heat out of your house.
- Structural Damage: Water seeping into the roof can loosen shingles, rot the wooden roof deck, and even tear gutters clean off the house under the weight of the ice.
- Interior Aesthetic Issues: You’ll see the signs eventually: stains on the ceiling, peeling paint, or bubbling wallpaper. By the time you see a brown spot on your ceiling, the water has likely been there for days.
- The Mold Factor: This is the big one. Damp wood and wet insulation in a dark attic are the perfect breeding ground for mold and mildew. This can lead to air quality issues for your family long after the snow has melted.
- Floor and Wall Warp: If the leak is significant enough, water can travel down the interior of the walls, warping your sheetrock and even damaging hardwood floors on the main level.
Proactive Prevention: Keeping the Dams at Bay
At Calfee Insurance, we believe the best insurance claim is the one that never has to be filed. While we shop the top carriers like Plymouth Rock, Arbella, Safety, and Travelers to ensure you have the best protection possible, we’d much rather help you keep your home dry.
Here are the gold-standard prevention tips:
1. Clear Your Gutters Early
This should be a fall tradition. Clearing your gutters before the first snowflake falls ensures that when melting does occur, the water has a clear path to the downspouts. If gutters are full of leaves, they trap water, which freezes into a solid block of ice, kickstarting the damming process.
2. Insulate and Seal Your Attic
The goal is a "cold roof." You want the temperature of your roof to match the outside air as closely as possible. This means keeping your home's heat inside the living space. Check for leaks around air ducts, chimneys, and light fixtures. Adding extra insulation to your attic floor is one of the best investments a Cape Cod homeowner can make.
3. Ensure Proper Ventilation
A well-ventilated attic allows cold air to circulate under the roof deck. This prevents "hot spots" from forming. If your home doesn't have a ridge vent or soffit vents, it might be time to talk to a contractor.

What to Do If an Ice Dam Forms
If you look up today and see a massive wall of ice, don't panic: but do act carefully. Some DIY "fixes" can actually make the situation worse or lead to serious injury.
Safety First: What NOT to Do
- Don’t go on the roof. It sounds obvious, but every year people try to shovel their roofs while standing on them. One slip on a patch of black ice can be life-changing.
- Don’t "chip" at the ice. Taking a hammer or an ice pick to a dam is a great way to put a hole through your shingles. You’ll end up with more leaks than you started with.
The "Stocking Trick"
This is a classic New England hack that actually works. If you have an active dam, take an old pair of nylon stockings and fill them with a calcium chloride ice melt (avoid rock salt, as it can damage your shingles and kill your landscaping).
Tie the end and use a long-handled rake or broom to lay the stocking vertically across the ice dam so that it overhangs the gutter. The calcium chloride will slowly melt a channel through the ice, allowing the trapped water to flow off the roof safely.
Use a Roof Rake
To prevent the dam from getting larger, use a long-handled roof rake to pull fresh snow off the first three to four feet of your roof while standing safely on the ground. This removes the "fuel" that the ice dam needs to grow.
Protecting Your Investment with the Right Coverage
Sometimes, despite our best efforts, the weather wins. When that happens, you want to know that your home insurance is up to the task.
As a local agency, we don't just sell policies; we provide peace of mind. We take the time to explain the difference between replacement cost and actual cash value, ensuring that if your roof or interior is damaged, you have the funds to fix it properly.
Because we represent multiple top-tier carriers, we can shop around to find the best fit for your specific property. Whether it's looking for Travelers insurance discounts or exploring the comprehensive options from Safety Insurance and Arbella, we’ve got your back.
We’re Here for Cape Cod
For over four decades, Davidson Calfee and the entire team at Arthur D. Calfee Insurance Agency have been part of this community. We’ve seen the blizzards of ’78, the hurricanes, and countless winter cycles. We know that your home is likely your biggest asset, and we take protecting it personally.
If you’re worried about your current coverage or want to make sure you’re protected before the next big storm hits, give us a call or stop by the office. We can review your policy, look for gaps, and make sure you’re getting the best rates available from carriers like Plymouth Rock and Encompass.
Stay warm, stay safe, and let’s keep those roofs clear this winter!

Disclaimer: Some tasks related to roof maintenance and ice removal are inherently dangerous. If you are uncomfortable performing these tasks, we strongly recommend hiring a licensed and insured professional contractor. Safety should always be your top priority.


